You can tell it was an excellent ValleyCon at the weekend because it has got me thinking, pondering and plotting. The credit for that goes to Allen Yaxley for organising and running the DBMM competition so well. You did a great job, Allen, thank you.
This post is not a report of my four games at ValleyCon, which will come later. Instead, this is thoughts about Thracians. A couple of months ago I took my Thracian army out of my toy soldiers’ China cabinet – I rotate my armies, using one for about six months to a year, then using another. The Thracians have played six games this time round, the last four at the weekend at ValleyCon, and four games in two days is a great way to focus the mind.
And my thoughts? I am happy with the tweak I made to my list, replacing the 11 horse archers (Irr LH(F)) I previously used as a separate command with 11 javelin-armed light horse (Irr LH(O)). That worked well. What needs changing are two parts of my tactical approach and I have a question mark beside a third.
First, don’t flank march unless absolutely necessary. The army’s strength is there is so much of it (104 morale equivalents (ME)) in 400 points and most of it is nimble. I have flank marched in three games and now realise having those troops off the table took away from my advantage in numbers. None of the three flank marches provided any useful advantage, and two of them didn’t even arrive!
Secondly, the nobles (Irr Kn(I) in wedge) are not like “proper” knights and should seldom lead an attack. Importantly, they add a good number of ME and staying power to the King’s command and to the army but they are decidedly vulnerable when rolling low combat dice. Twice they proved that at ValleyCon, one game when attacking a smaller group of Iranian nobles (Irr Kn(F)) and in a second after chasing a smaller group of horse archers (LH(F)) into rough ground. Both times three elements of Thracian nobles were doubled and destroyed taking out no Iranians and only one horse archer!
The question mark is about Xenophon, who leads the Greek mercenary command of hoplites and peltasts (all Reg, Sp(O) and Ps(S)). Historically, Greek hoplite generals fought in the front – that was just the totally expected style of heroic leadership. I have been doing that in games but am not sure this is good thing. Twice at ValleyCon Xenophon could not be doubled in a straight-up fight but could be if there was an overlap on one flank. The lines closed, an overlap happened, then Xenophon copped 6-1 against ordinary cavalry and 6-1 against ordinary pikes, dead both times. The odds of that happening are low but the consequences are dreadful. He may have to be, unhistorically, in the rear.
At ValleyCon I won one, lost one and had a winning draw and a losing draw. It occurred to me as I thought, pondered and plotted, my win was the only game where I neither flank marched my light horse command nor attacked with the nobles. The light horse forced my opponent to commit troops and PIPs to go wide and stop a possible envelopment. Those were troops and PIPs that could not be used to go forward. The nobles moved to a flank and drew the cluster of elephants away. Neither the elephants nor my nobles fought as there were plenty of his and my troops between them. But that was okay because the elephants were not attacking my hoplites, who, without having to worry about being stomped by elephants, won the game for me.
In the winning draw I got a bit lucky when I attacked ordinary cavalry with the nobles – none of the nobles were doubled in the first round of close combat. In following rounds as our lines intermingled, my wedges not being able to be overlapped began to give me an advantage. Later, I realised the light horse command that I had held as a reserve added greatly to that advantage and without it I would probably not have broken my opponent’s cavalry command. My light horse sub-general used his PIPs to feed more and more light horse into the fight to threaten a flank, plug gaps and exploit overlaps. He couldn’t have done that if he was flank marching.
See you at the DBMM Nationals and hopefully these thoughts about Thracians will prove useful! Andrew Bennetts is running the Nationals, June 3-4 at St Brendan’s School, Upper Hutt, Andrew.bennetts@mw.com https://www.facebook.com/.../8248.../posts/2301900653302847/
King Seuthes II |
Nobles, Irr Kn(I) in wedge |
Xenophon |
An excellent reference |
Book 1, list 48 |
400 points of Thracians boxed to travel |
No comments:
Post a Comment